November 17, 2026 | Mark Luis Foster

As we scrub the world wide web for HOA disputes, we sometimes come across fence-building issues, which are quite ironic when you think about it. Here’s one from our eastern neighbors in ‘Sconi.

The story revolves around Lisa and Michael Newman, who live in the Nazcr Trac subdivision in De Pere, Wisconsin. The couple wanted to install a backyard fence so their children, who have disabilities, could safely enjoy outdoor activities without wandering away from home.

The family’s medical providers and caregivers supported the need for a secure outdoor space. But there was a problem.

The subdivision’s governing documents contained a restriction stating that fences were prohibited. When the family requested an exception in 2019, the HOA board denied the request, citing the existing covenant and previous decisions denying fences to other homeowners.

The family maintained that its circumstances were different because the fence was needed to accommodate their children’s disabilities. After unsuccessful efforts to obtain approval, the Newmans filed a federal lawsuit in 2021 alleging violations of the Fair Housing Act.

So in May 2022, U.S. District Judge William Griesbach granted a preliminary injunction preventing the association from enforcing its fence prohibition against the family while the litigation continued.

The decision allowed the family to construct the fence. Turns out the federal Fair Housing Act protects individuals with disabilities from discrimination in housing. Those protections can require homeowner associations to make reasonable exceptions to rules or permit reasonable physical modifications when necessary for residents with disabilities to use and enjoy their homes.

A rule that applies equally to every homeowner may still require an exception when federal disability protections apply.

In August 2024, the parties reached a settlement requiring the association to pay the family $200,000. But the settlement was not a final trial verdict establishing every allegation, but it created a significant financial obligation.

Now the Neighbors Are Being Sued

According to reporting published November 13, 2026, by NBC 26 in Green Bay, the association’s settlement was to be funded through payments of approximately $1,350 per homeowner.

Many residents paid. Others refused, arguing that they had not participated in the decision to deny the fence and should not be responsible for the resulting settlement.

The family’s attorney reported that 55 homeowners had still not paid. The Newmans have now filed another lawsuit involving the association and homeowners with outstanding payments.

Some residents who already paid worry that they could face additional financial exposure if the remaining settlement obligations are not satisfied. The new litigation remains unresolved.

For Minnesota HOA boards, the message is clear: Sometimes the most important question isn’t whether the rules prohibit something, but whether the law requires the association to make an exception.

You can read / watch the whole fence building story HERE.

Leave A Comment